| Platinum | Taylor's Tin Cakes |
| Gold | OhMyGoodies! By Sara Jean |
| Silver | Tayts Cakes |
| Bronze | Shana Cake |
| Top Pick | Heather's Cakes |
| Top Pick | Kristin's Creations |
| Top Pick | Mikayla's Kreations |
| Top Pick | Shantyl's Cakes & More |
| Top Pick | Sweet as Cake |
| Top Pick | Sweet Eats by Kelly |